Not Always Strong
September 2nd, 2006On Wednesday, the day after my lymphoma diagnosis, I started to feel that communication between me and the painter (he is back at his house in Baton Rouge now, two hours away) was becoming strange, confusing, and somehow very stilted. I asked him what was going on, and after some back and forth, he finally sent me a long angry email in which he unleashed many complaints about me, a lot of them things he’d never before told me. He closed by saying, “But admit it, you have been trying to mold me into something I’m just not.”
Below is the exchange between us that followed. My letters have the >> in front of them.
Me:
>I tried to listen to you, I really did. I read and
> reread this long rambling confusing letter many times
> over, trying to hear and understand what you were
> saying. I’m trying my best to understand what happened
> to the love between us. If I misunderstood, if this
> wasn’t about dumping anger and hostility and
> resentment on me, then please explain so I can
> understand. Every time I read it, I see a long litany
> of resentments and accusations, going back to the very
> beginning. It sounds very angry to me. Telling me to
> “lighten up” the day after I got a grim cancer
> diagnosis seems more like anger and hostility than
> love or understanding. (And saying “I’m tempted to
> tell you but I won’t because I respect you” is the
> same as telling me.)
> If I’m mistaken, and you’re not angry and
> resentful, then please help me understand what you ARE
> saying. Break it down for me. I AM listening. How have
> I tried to mold you? Spell it out for for me, please
> make a list. I’m not asking so I can defend myself
> or attack you, I honestly want to understand what I
> have done to make you feel that way.
>
> How exactly have I not allowed you to be yourself? All
> I can figure out from this email is that somehow
> because I didn’t love your white loafers, you believe
> I was trying to change you, refusing to accept you,
> “piling ridicule” on you. [Painter], that’s just about a
> pair of shoes, not about you. And I never told you not
> to wear them. I kidded you gently about them once. I’m
> sorry, I didn’t realize that would hurt you so much.
> But besides the shoes, what else? Please tell me
> exactly how I’ve tried to mold you into something you
> aren’t, how I’ve tried to make you change. When did I
> dismiss you as feeble? I can’t read your mind. I don’t
> understand and I want to.
>
> I’m genuinely trying to listen, and honestly willing
> to hear your feedback, and I want figure out what I
> need to do to stop making you feel like I’m not
> accepting you, because I always have accepted you.
> More than just accepted you, I’ve celebrated you,
> loved you, told the whole world how great you are. I
> don’t know what more I can do, so I’m open to
> suggestions.
>
> Tell me, how can I ask for what I need, things like
> kindness, emotional support, less yelling, etc.,
> without it seeming like I’m trying to mold you into
> what you’re not? Is it possible?
The painter:
I can’t make a list of 10 things you want to change about me. It’s one big thing. I feel what you want me to be is some whimpering little weasel who bows down to every complaint you make about me or my behavior. It appears that you want a spineless wimp. Your method is “you’re not hearing me”. That is a predetermined discussion terminator and a hands-down argument winner every time. I don’t like to argue any more than most people, but a defense doesn’t mean I don’t listen to you. It means I act in certain ways naturally and, though I’m often willing to change some of that, I’m not going to stop being me and become a drooling wimp. I’m not one. I don’t know if those sort of men choose to be that way or if it comes naturally. But I’m not going to choose to become one, and I sure wasn’t born to be one either. If you don’t like the vocal, forceful man I am, you should look for a different sort of man.
(Another list of complaints about me followed. From here on, this isn’t a back and forth exchange, it’s the painter replying to my letter, with his replies interspersed between what I said.)
Me:
> Hi, thank you for taking the time to put this together
> and express these things. I know it isn’t easy, but
> this letter is very helpful for me. I never realized
> how you felt about some of these things, and now that
> I do, we can maybe work towards a solution that will
> make us both happier.
>
> We do have a big problem. It seems that maybe when I
> have tried to express my needs, when I’ve asked you
> for empathy and kindness, to care about my emotions,
> to rein in the anger and yelling when you’re around
> me, somehow you heard me demanding that you be “some
> whimpering little weasel who bows down to every
> complaint” and “a spineless drooling wimp.”
The painter:
Yes, that is correct. That’s it pretty much in a nut shell.
Me:
> I’m not sure if this is a misunderstanding, a
> miscommunication, a projection, or just a basic
> disagreement about the definition of wimp.
>
> Just out curiosity and maybe clarification, tell me
> something. You may have observed a little bit of the
> way Finnie, for example, is able to tune in to
> emotional needs, to express his own emotions and
> listen with kindness and understanding to others. He’s
> extremely gentle with animals and small children, he
> doesn’t raise his voice in conversations, and he
> listens very carefully to Lia (and to me) when she has
> a complaint or request. He cares about how the people
> around him feel, and about how his words and actions
> affect them.
>
> Do you think of Finnie as a “spineless whimpering
> drooling little weasel”? Is he incapable of also being
> vocal and forceful, is he a failure at accomplishing
> what he sets out to do, is he a “compliant little
> weakling” because he is gentle and and kind and
> sensitive to the emotional needs of the women around
> him: his wife, his mother, his friends, his
> self-defense students, and rape victims everywhere?
‘
The painter:
I am not saying that everyone who behaves in ways that I don’t is a wimp. But make no mistake about it, for me to behave in the way you suggest, a behavior which is the only way I can show empathy and kindness, and to help you, I would have to become a wimp. Worse, if I were to try to keep up this charade, I would eventually come unglued. I can not be something I’m not.
Some people handle things differently than others. Who is to say one is better than the other. Your comments suggest that one is, at least when you are involved. I don’t have any problem with that. If that is the only way you can be helped, if any other way is unacceptable, then you should know that I am not the guy for the job. I’m not, never have been, nor ever will be passive about such things. I take charge. I’m very good at it, and it has never failed me. Not one time. If a member of my family (that would be you) needs help and isn’t getting it, tell the persons who should be responsible to look out. If they don’t shape up, I’ll not only be on the warpath, I’ll do everything in my power to get them fired. I’m not joking. I’ve done it before, and doubt that could be stopped if I decide such action needs to be taken again. I just may prevent someone else from suffering in the future. I get things done.
I have no doubt that Finnie is a wonder, caring, loving, helpful young man. He may be wiser than I could ever be. He owes that to you, I suppose. Obviously, he and I have very different styles. If you can only accept a man who is similar to Finnie, again, you’ll have to look elsewhere. I’m 59 years old, I have had my successes, and I’m not interested in changing my ways one iota, not now. It’s worked very well for me up to now. I’m certain it will continue to work for me in the future.
Me:
> Do you think that I am a spineless wimp because my body
> doesn’t make testosterone?
The painter:
I use that term because it had started to feel like you expect me to check my balls at your door before I come into your house and your life. It’s really starting to drive me away. I tried to comply, but it just felt so wrong, and it got worse every time I came over. But I tried to be delicate, knowing how much you meant to me and of course in light of your condition.
Me:
> It may be that we’re not in total disagreement, just
> misunderstanding each other. In that case, we can work
> constructively to clear it up and set things straight.
The painter:
I’m not unwilling to work on a solution as long as the solution isn’t an attempt to change who I am. I’m not sure what will work. I figure that is the point of going to a professional. I’m not even sure anything will work. I know I’m terribly uncomfortable with the current direction I feel I’m being pushed.
Me:
> So let me see if I understood your other points.
>
> I hear you say you wish I would participate more often
> in political discussions about the topics that
> interest you. I see no problem there, all you had to
> do was ask. I already read the news without prompting,
> and will be happy to work on fixing that problem.
> Thanks for letting me know how you feel, and please
> keep offering feedback when you feel it’s needed. I’m
> sorry I never understood that this was something you
> felt was missing.
The painter:
That’s just one small example. You dismiss me almost constantly, time after time. I’ll give you a much better example. I pointed out my objection to you working sudoku puzzles when we are eating together. You never missed a lick. I’ve sat and watched you work those puzzles while I did nothing for I figure several hours now. I wish the fucking things had never been invented. But if it weren’t them, it’d be word scrambles or crossword puzzles.
Then the other day, after playing with one of the puzzles while you were in the shower, I came up with an idea that some people (I realize purists wouldn’t want to do it this way) might find helpful, a way to work the puzzles without having to make erasures, or fear of making them. I turned to a puzzle in the area of the book you had been working on and duplicated it on the mock-up I’d made. I showed it to you. We ate our meals and then you pushed it to the side, turned the page in your book and worked another puzzle. It was unquestionably the second most offensive thing anyone has ever done to me. The only way it could have been even more offensive is if you’d pushed it off on to the floor. I casually picked up my puzzle and went to the bedroom to read. Later, I took my puzzle to the car and left it there. I’d spent a little over a hour making the thing, but first chance I got I threw it away. I was trembling I was so offended. Only Louie Finklestein has ever offended me worse. I can not over emphasize how incredibly rude this act was. On a scale of 1 to 10, it was easily an 11! There have been others, plenty of them. But that was by far the worst.
It proved beyond a doubt that you think my intelligence is inferior to yours. You go girl. Have I made that clear? I’m trying to not overstate this point. You could not have found anything more offensive to do. Nothing would have served that end better. I was appalled. Unbelievable.
Me:
> And I hear you saying you are very angry at me for not
> going to the doctor sooner. Is that correct?
>
> And I hear you saying you are afraid that I won’t let
> you help me if a time comes when the medical system is
> failing me. The truth is, I do want and need your
> help, not just the standing by being quietly
> supportive kind, but the loud vocal fighting kind. But
> I need it when the time is right: if I’m not getting
> the pain meds I need, for instance, I would love to
> think that you would be exactly like the wife in that
> story by the English Patient in Philadelphia, that
> your head would explode and wipe out half of
> Lafayette. I’m not asking that you refrain from going
> into battle mode, only that you choose your battles
> wisely. And that you not totally forget about ME when
> you’re off in the glory of battle.
>
> Did I miss anything?
The painter:
Yes, something huge. You and I spent the entire night from 10 PM until 5 AM in the emergency room [at the charity hospital, several weeks ago] and then they gave you a prescription that couldn’t even be filled. On the way down to Lafayette, I told you that if it were up to me, we’d go to [a private hospital in town]. We had already determined that you were going to have to pay for the treatment either way. Then after you missed yet another entire night of very much needed sleep, you attacked me for pointing that out. If we had used my judgment, we would both have gotten a good nights sleep, you’d have gotten your shot and a prescription you could have filled. Just another failure on the part of the charity hospital system that we should have bypassed.
Me:
> What I would suggest is, rather than haggling over
> this point by point, we print out this email and take
> it to the couples therapist, if you are still
> interested in trying that. This seems like a good
> place to start learning how to communicate with each
> other better.
The painter:
I’m more than willing to do that. What that will have to entail for me to participate is this though. We must bear witness to the facts. That the failures of the system, the bureaucrats and incompetent doctors, could have been eliminated.
Me:
> I have an individual therapy appointment next Wednesday
> with a therapist who has an
> office on South Main Street. Wanda knows a lot of
> people who go to her. So slowly, I’m trying to make
> progress through this mess.
>
> Thank you again for taking the time and trouble and
> risk of being honest. I appreciate it.
>
> I want you to know that I love you very much, even
> when we’re not getting along, and I’m willing to do
> whatever I can to make things better. I am not The
> Enemy. I do appreciate everything you’ve done for me,
> with all my heart. Right now I miss my friend, and my
> lover. I want him back. I sincerely hope we can make
> that happen soon, in spite of this horrendous
> stressful nightmare we’ve been plunged into.
The painter:
I expect that you are reeling about now. As you must be able to see, I’m not too sure that you aren’t the enemy, and I almost positive your are your worst enemy. And I’m thinking what you are really missing is someone you can push around at will. I could not feel any worse about what has happened to you health-wise. Or us, for that matter. I’d give anything if I could change this nightmare. I’ve tried to be delicate because of it. But I feel you’ve bulldozed over me time and time again. I could try to let it pass again, but eventually, I have to be me and standup for myself. There is no way that I could keep on like this. It just wouldn’t work endlessly.
Me (in a later email, but before I had received his above reply):
> It seems to me that like many people (especially many
> men), when you’re confronted with a situation that’s
> scary, sad, painful, frustrating, one where you feel
> helpless to fix the big picture (i.e., cure cancer),
> it makes you feel better if you can at least get mad
> and put up a good fight against something. And the
> nightmare of the public health system is a very good
> target, as would be the health insurance situation in
> the US.
>
> Whereas I feel more empowered by striving for
> serenity, a quiet inner strength, and a positive
> rather than negative attitude, for you, the anger and
> fighting are more likely to help calm your anxiety,
> and help make you feel less helpless, more powerful
> and effective and in control, closer to being able to
> offer a solution. Does this sound right so far?
>
> Ok. But then a problem arises if sometimes you get so
> caught up in the blame & fight mode that your anger
> spills over onto innocent bystanders. Once you turn it
> on, it sometimes doesn’t want to be turned off, and
> suddenly everything in sight can become a target if it
> doesn’t move out of your way fast enough. This may
> result in you lashing out at people who are genuinely
> trying to help, blaming the cleaning lady for being
> complicit in maintaining The System, etc.
>
> And unfortunately it also sometimes results in you
> directing your anger full force on me. So instead of
> focusing on helping me like you originally intended,
> you end up blaming me, yelling at me, saying things
> that hurt me as you lash out against your own pain but
> end up attacking me instead.
>
> Anyway, this is what it often feels like to me. So
> when I ask you to rein in your anger and yelling, I’m
> not asking you to roll over and become a passive wimp.
> I’m just asking you to please not make ME the target.
> I know it’s often hard to carry two mindsets at once,
> so it may be challenging to direct your fury at the
> system while simultaneously being kind and gentle
> towards me when I need it. Challenging, but I hope not
> impossible.
>
> Does this make sense, does it help you understand any
> better where I’m coming from? If not, tell me and I
> will listen.
>
> I’m trying.
>
> Love,
>-L.
The painter:
I think this is the kind of thing that therapists are for. But I will say again what I said in the first message. If I’m to help, my suggestions have to be considered equally. I’m still positive (that’s with a capital P) that we should have gone to one of the closer hospitals instead of [the charity hospital]. You will undoubtedly point out that they did have your charts. That’s what took 7 hours to find. Ludicrous. I’d have gladly paid to have another x-ray to have avoided you missing another full night of sleep. And add the fight to that. Man, did that ever suck. The whole affair is so fresh in my memory. Can I make it clearer that I think it was totally uncalled for and unnecessary? And that there was an easy solution–and I had it right from the start. It’s been two weeks tonight and I’m still sure we missed a great opportunity to get you some real professional help that night.
My heart is breaking, and I don’t know what to do. I can’t figure out how to get through to him, how reach across this huge divide between us and bring back the love and friendship. I can’t understand why he has suddenly turned on me like this, or where all this cold anger and fury is coming from. Was it always there, and I just didn’t see it? No doubt we have both made mistakes, but I am trying so hard now to understand and find a way to work through the mess. It may be several weeks before we can arrange to see a couples therapist, and by then I fear it will be too late. He is moving away from me faster than I can try to reach out and fix things.
In many ways, this loss of my love is harder on me than the cancer diagnosis, and that they both happened at the same time is overwhelming me. I can fight against cancer, but there’s nothing I can do if the painter’s love has irrevocably turned to hostility and blame.
I have been trying so hard to stay positive and make the best of things, to still find some joy in life. But now I don’t know what to do. I feel so hurt and discouraged and defeated, the will to keep up my strong positive attitude is slowly draining out of me. I honestly don’t know where to turn.



















I'm fifty-two years old. I have a compulsive hair-cutting disorder. I write, I dance, I lift big heavy weights. I live in the land of alligators, Spanish moss, and drive-thru daiquiris. We have roaches the size of Buicks! The people down here speak French and eat deep-fried pig penises. Sometimes I wonder why the hell I don't quite fit in.